Games » Boston Red Sox
Aug27Not horrible, not great
Lee Judge
The Kansas City Star
Last Tuesday Luke Hochevar had a great start against the Tampa Bay Rays: eight innings, one hit, 10 strikeouts and no runs. Six days later, against the Boston Red Sox, the only one of those numbers Luke was able to duplicate was the eight innings. Luke allowed eight hits, had six strikeouts and gave up five runs, four of them earned. Four earned runs in Fenway Park is not a disaster, and Hochevar’s eight innings gave the bullpen some much-needed rest.
This was not a meltdown, but still a disappointing outing after the last one. Hochevar wasn’t horrible, he wasn’t great, but after his previous start, Royals fans were hoping for more.
Game notes
Jarrod Dyson started the game by walking, stealing second and advancing to third on the catcher’s bad throw. With Dyson on third and nobody down, Alcides Escobar needed to get a pitch up in the zone (that could be hit to the outfield) or a pitch that could be driven up the middle (with the infield playing back). Instead, Escobar swung at an inside fastball and pulled it to third — one of the few balls in play that would not score Dyson.
Alex Gordon did a better job of situational hitting and drove the ball in the air to right field. Cody Ross caught it, but Dyson was able to tag and score.
Scott Podsednik started the Red Sox half of the inning by striking out looking. Scott did that a lot — especially for a fast guy who hits from the left side — when he was here in KC.
Jarrod Dyson used the wall to catch Dustin Pedroia’s deep fly ball to centerfield. Some outfielders are intimidated by the wall and slow down when they hit the warning track. The Royals have a group of outfielders who know how to use the wall: jump up, plant your spikes in the padding and use the traction to go even higher.
The bad news is the ball was hit over 400 feet. Hochevar threw three 92 mph 4-seam fastballs to Pedroia, and Pedroia hit the third one a long way. Hochevar then threw four more 92 mph 4-seam fastballs (at least according to MLB.com) to Jacoby Ellsbury, and Ellsbury hit the fourth one out of the park — barely — in right.
That’s a lot of 92 mph 4-seam fastballs in a row, especially for a guy who’s supposed to be getting “separation” in speeds.
In the thirrd inning Podsednik did a better job of protecting with two strikes, fouling a couple pitches off before singling to right. Pedroia also singled and then miscommunication cost the Royals another run: with a runner on second base the signs the catcher gives the pitcher get more complicated. If someone forgets the sequence it’s not unusual to see a cross up. The catcher expects one pitch and gets another. Fans will know when a wild pitch or passed ball is a cross up because the catcher will immediately visit the mound to straighten things out.
Perez met with Hochevar, but the damage had been done: Podsednik and Pedroia had advanced a base so when Cody Ross hit a ball off the wall, two runs scored instead of one.
Alex Gordon — who played the Green Monster well all weekend — grabbed the carom and threw Ross out at second to end the inning.
On an 0-2 count to Jarrod Saltalamacchia, Perez signaled Hochevar to throw the ball up out of the zone. Luke missed in the zone and the Red Sox catcher pulled the ball into the left field stands. Saltalamacchia eventually grounded out to Eric Hosmer, but missing his target by a foot or so helps explain what was going on with Hochevar in this game.
Johnny Giavotella seemed to be more aggressive on hittable pitches early in the count and singled and doubled. The double went off the left field wall and once again Podsednik got too close to the wall, the ball bounced over him and once again Jacoby Ellsbury was in position to make the play.
Gordon hit his 42nd double of the season, many of them hustle doubles. Right fielder Cody Ross throws left-handed and the ball was in the right center gap. That meant Ross would have to make an awkward pivot and have little momentum behind his throw. Good base runners pay attention to this kind of stuff and know when they can push it on the base paths.
Gordon then advanced on Salvador Perez’s F9. With two down, getting to third is usually not that big a deal, but as we’ve been seeing all weekend, scoring from second on a single to left in Fenway Park is not a sure thing.
In the 6th Dyson got too close to the wall and Gordon backed him up. (Gordon and Ellsbury need to make an instructional video.)
Luke Hochevar will sometimes use a “quick pitch” to upset a hitter’s timing. As long as the hitter is in the box and set, it’s not illegal. Luke often does it with two strikes and hopes to catch the hitter off-guard for a called strike three. He tried it with an 0-2 count on Podsednik and Scott was ready, lining the ball into center field.
Once Podsednik got to first, he stared at the mound and then started laughing. The camera shot did not include Hochevar, but I’m guessing Luke said something about Scott — an ex-teammate — not being fooled by the tactic.
The Royals last chance
After seven innings and 101 pitches, Bobby Valentine pulled Daisuke Matsuzaka. Daisuke has the reputation of working slow and nibbling, but Monday afternoon he was working quickly and throwing strikes. When a starting pitcher is dominating, Plan B usually goes like this: stay close, get the starter out of the game and win it against the bullpen.
So when Clayton Mortensen replaced Matsuzaka, the Royals needed to get something going in a hurry. They had six outs to work with and needed four runs, not impossible in Fenway. And if they could get all four runs in the eighth, they might keep the Red Sox from using Andrew Bailey (their current closer who’s sporting a 1.69 ERA) in the ninth.
Mortensen started by striking out Alcides Escobar, then gave up a single to Alex Gordon. (According to Steve Physioc that was Gordon’s 48th multi-hit game, the third most in the American League.)
Time out: I’ve been praised for giving credit when I use information I get from another source, but it’s not that I’m such a great guy — if the numbers are wrong I want you to blame Steve.
Ok, where were we? Oh, yeah, Gordon singled and so did Billy Butler. Salvador Perez was at the plate and the tying run was on-deck. Unfortunately, Bobby Valentine was not going to let the Royals get anything going against Mortensen and replaced him Vicente Padilla. After two quick strikes Padilla got Perez to hit the ball on the ground and a quick 4-6-3 double play later and the Royals’ threat was over.
Back home
The Royals start a 10-game home stand. They’ll face Detroit, Minnesota and Texas before heading back out on the road. Tuesday night the scheduled starters are Justin Verlander and Luis Mendoza.
Royals coach Eddie Rodriquez shows Lee Judge proper throwing technique
Kansas City Royals coach Eddie Rodriquez shows Lee Judge proper baseball throwing techniques. 8/17/12 (Video by John Sleezer/The Kansas City Star)

Hochevar
Gordon
Dyson
Daniel Wesley
8 months, 3 weeks agoMy frustration is rapidly turning into apathy. Add to that Dayton Moore’s announcement on sports radio that the Royals won’t be competitive next year, it almost makes me want to become a football fan. :(
Jim Wilson
8 months, 3 weeks agoLee, I agree Luke’s start wasn’t horrible and it wasn’t great but I think you’re a little hard him (imagine that!). It was a lot closer to great than horrible. I would call it very solid. A game score of 53 (50 and above is a quality start), 6 Ks, 1 walk and 8 hits in 8 innings. We need a lot more of that. Luke doesn’t need to avoid or even improve on nights like tonight he just needs to throw the occasional gem and have a lot less horrible starts.
Daniel Wesley
8 months, 3 weeks agoJim, what has Luke Hochevar done over his career to earn the benefit of any doubt?
Josh Cooper
8 months, 3 weeks agoDaniel, when and on what station did Moore say that?
Daniel Wesley
8 months, 3 weeks agoJosh, it was on August 3rd… on Soren Petro’s midday show on 810 WHB.
Joel Kallem
8 months, 3 weeks agoNice article by Sam Mellinger in the Star today which points out many of the things that have been commented about on this site without some of the bombastic overkill that some of us use when we are so upset over a particularly bad Royal loss.
Lee Judge
8 months, 3 weeks agoJim: You may be right about being too hard on Luke. It may be more my fault than his. You see him do what he did in Tampa Bay and think maybe now he’s got it and will roll off a string of similar starts, but that might be unrealistic.
Like I said, I don’t think four earned runs in Fenway over eight innings is horrible.
Daniel: Luke Hochevar is without doubt inconsistent, but if he weren’t outstanding at times, the team would have given up on him.
Here’s what he’s done this season that would make some people give him the benefit of the doubt: 6.1 innings, 2 earned runs against Los Angeles/6.1 innings, 2 earned runs against Cleveland/7 innings, 0 earned runs against Chicago/9 innings, 0 earned runs against Tampa Bay/7 innings, 1 earned run against Minnesota/6 innings, 1 earned run against Texas and 8 innings, 0 earned runs against Tampa Bay.
Obviously, Hochevar has had some mediocre starts and a couple meltdowns or we wouldn’t be having this conversation. But there’s not a lot of good starting pitching available, so the Royals keep trying to figure out how to get the best out of Hochevar on a more consistent basis.
P.S. I’d have to hear the Dayton Moore quote in it’s entirety to give it credence. That doesn’t sound like something a GM would be likely to say.
Joel: Yeah, it sounds like Sam has come to some of the same conclusions I have. If it makes anyone feel any better, that’s the consensus view of the people out at the park who see every game and have been doing that for a few years.
I think that experience gives them some context and keeps them from freaking out over a bad game.
Josh Cooper
8 months, 3 weeks agoThanks, Daniel. I have a few friends that were willing to give him a pass on 2012 because 6 years isn’t enough time to build a winner. I disagree with them, but they said they would come to my side if 2013 was also a losing season. Will be interested to hear what their excuses will be this time.
Jim Wilson
8 months, 3 weeks agoDaniel, I’m not giving him the benefit of the doubt with respect to anything. He pitched a good game and he should be recognized for it. Same when he pitches poorly.
Aaron Reese
8 months, 3 weeks agoThis start made it difficult to determine how well Hochevar was sequencing pitches because Boston was aggressive. Boston had 9 plate appearances with two pitches or less. It’s tough to tell if he’s sequencing well or not on just two pitches. On those PAs with 3 pitches or more, on good sequenced plate appearances (disregarding control), Boston hit .272/.333/.272 with 3 Ks. On poorly sequenced PAs, they hit .272/.272/.636 with 3 Ks also.
Brendan Woodbury
8 months, 3 weeks agoJim W -
In today’s lower run-scoring environment, I’d think the average game score is quite a bit higher than it was a few years ago. Have you seen any updated figures on what’s an average game score in 2011-12?
Jim Wilson
8 months, 3 weeks agoNo, but a 53.0 average would put you at 17 out of the 39 qualified pitchers in the AL. A 54.2 would put you in the top 10 in the league. Beyond the game score (which is heavily impacted by runs scored), I liked the 6.0 K/BB ratio and the 1.125 WHIP.
Jim Wilson
8 months, 3 weeks agoUsing a cut-off of 100 innings, a 53.0 average would out you at 22 out of 54 in the AL. So I think it’s fair to say that a 53 is an above average outing.